Should I just hire the agent who sold my neighbor's house?

An agent who sold your neighbor's house already has recent, directly comparable data for your street, which is genuinely useful, but it is still worth asking how they will price and market your specific home rather than assuming a repeat performance. Your home's condition, updates, and timing can differ enough from your neighbor's to change the strategy. Brian welcomes that comparison and will tell you honestly if your situation calls for a different approach.